Skip to content
BTR Trading Group

Understanding Managed Futures

Most portfolios are built for one kind of market. Yours does not have to be.

Inflation, changing rates, slowdowns and shifting sentiment all create stretches where stocks and bonds struggle together. Managed futures can add a return source that does not depend on either of them continuing to rise — traded by a professional, in an account that stays in your name. What it is, what it costs and what can go wrong, below.

Educational information only. Nothing here is a recommendation to trade or an offer of any program. Managed futures are speculative, involve a substantial risk of loss and are not suitable for all investors.

Start here

Managed futures, in plain English

It sounds like an asset class. It is closer to an arrangement: a contract type, a professional licensed to trade it, and an account that belongs to you. Depending on the program, a manager may trade stock index futures, interest rates, currencies, energy, metals and agricultural markets — often all of them.

A futures contract

An agreement to buy or sell a defined quantity of something at a set price on a set date — crude oil, the S&P 500, ten-year notes, Japanese yen, gold, corn. It trades on a regulated exchange, it is priced continuously, and you can sell one before you own it just as easily as you can buy one. That last point is why these strategies are not tied to markets going up.

A trading advisor

A Commodity Trading Advisor, or CTA, is a firm registered with the CFTC and a member of the NFA that trades futures on behalf of clients. Each one publishes a disclosure document describing its program, its fees, its principals and its past performance in a format the regulator prescribes. You read it before you sign anything.

An account in your name

You open a futures account at a clearing firm, in your own name. The advisor gets written authority to place trades in it and nothing more — they cannot withdraw funds, and you can revoke that authority. This is what separates a managed account from a fund: you are not buying units of a pool, you hold the positions.

It can be positioned in either direction

A conventional investment generally makes money when the thing you own goes up. A managed futures program can also hold short positions, designed to gain when a market falls. It might be long some currencies and short others, or positioned for falling interest-rate futures while holding rising commodity markets at the same time.

This is a broader set of choices, not a form of certainty. Short positions lose money when markets rise, long positions lose money when markets fall, and both can be hurt by a sudden reversal. A manager can misread a market, and a rules-based signal can stay wrong for a long time.

Systematic or discretionary

A systematic program applies predefined rules, usually with computer models, and trades what the rules say. A discretionary program relies more on the research and judgment of the people running it. Some hold positions for months; others trade over much shorter periods.

Neither approach is inherently better. Two programs can trade the same markets and produce very different results, which is why the specific program matters more than the managed-futures label attached to it.

Who is who

CFTC Commodity Futures Trading Commission
The federal regulator for US futures markets.
NFA National Futures Association
The self-regulatory body. It registers firms, audits them and takes disciplinary action.
CTA Commodity Trading Advisor
The manager who makes the trading decisions in your account.
FCM Futures Commission Merchant
The clearing firm. It holds your money in segregated customer funds and issues your official statements.
IB Introducing Broker
What BTR is. We introduce and service the account; we never hold your money.
SMA Separately Managed Account
An account traded for one client alone, rather than a pool shared with other investors.

Why bother

Owning more is not the same as owning something different

A portfolio can hold dozens of funds and still depend on one outcome. Meaningful diversification comes from combining strategies with genuinely different return drivers — not from adding more of the same driver under different names.

More holdings are not always more diversification

Picture an account holding a large-company stock fund, a technology fund, an international stock fund and a real-estate securities fund. That is four investments, and every one of them is sensitive to equity valuations, financing conditions and investor appetite for risk. When those pressures intensify, several positions can fall together — which is precisely when the diversification was supposed to help.

Some investments described as alternatives also behave more like stocks in a stressed market than their label suggests. The label is not the exposure.

A different process, not a different ticker

Managed futures decisions may be driven by price movement, trends, relationships between markets or volatility, across currencies, rates, commodities and stock indexes. Those are different inputs from company earnings, dividends and bond income, so the results may differ from traditional assets over time.

That difference is the entire argument. It is also the entire risk: a process that does not track stocks and bonds can lose money in a year when stocks and bonds do well, and can lose money at the same time they do.

Correlation describes how far two investments have historically moved together. It is the number this whole discussion rests on, so it is worth being precise about what it does and does not tell you.

  • Positive correlation The two have tended to move in the same direction. Most stock funds are positively correlated with each other.
  • Negative correlation They have tended to move in opposite directions. Genuinely negative relationships are rarer than they are claimed to be.
  • Low correlation The relationship has been limited or inconsistent. This is what managed futures are usually described as offering — and it is a description of the past, not a promise about the future.

Correlations are measured over history and they change, particularly during periods of market stress. A strategy that behaved differently in the past may decline alongside your other holdings in the future. Managed futures are a potential diversifier, not portfolio insurance. Diversification does not assure a profit or protect against loss in declining markets. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.

Portable alpha, without the jargon

Keep your core. Add another potential return engine.

“Alpha” is return attributed to a manager’s decisions rather than to a market simply rising. “Portable alpha” means adding that independently managed return stream to a broader portfolio without necessarily replacing what is already in it.

  • Keep the core portfolio you already believe in
  • Add a separately managed program with its own return process
  • Judge the pair together, not the new piece on its own

Margin is not a down payment

Futures do not require you to put up the full value of a contract. You post margin — a good-faith deposit set by the exchange — and the position is marked to market every day, so gains and losses settle daily rather than accruing quietly until you sell. A contract controlling $100,000 of exposure might require a small fraction of that in margin.

This capital efficiency is what makes the portable-alpha structure possible at all: the program’s market exposure can be larger than the cash supporting it, which is how an allocation can sit alongside long-term holdings rather than replacing them.

The same efficiency is leverage

Gains and losses are calculated on the full exposure, not on the margin. Leverage magnifies both, and it magnifies the day-to-day swing in the account balance. Margin requirements can rise, and losses can exceed the amount deposited.

Judge the exposure by the program’s actual risk rather than by the cash currently supporting it. Portable alpha is a way of building a portfolio, not a free source of return — if the added strategy performs badly, the portfolio carries that result.

Notional funding cuts both ways

An advisor may accept an account funded below its nominal trading level — $250,000 of trading level on $100,000 of cash, for example. The program trades as though the full amount were there.

Percentage gains and percentage losses are both magnified against the cash you actually deposited, and a margin call arrives sooner. It is a legitimate structure that some investors use deliberately. It is not a discount.

Where the rest of the money sits

Because only part of the account is committed as margin, remaining assets may be held in eligible collateral, depending on the program, the clearing firm and the applicable requirements.

What counts as eligible, and what it earns, varies. It is a question worth asking before funding rather than after, because it changes the return on the cash you are not putting at risk.

Trading futures involves leverage, which can work against you as easily as for you. You can lose more than the amount you deposit as margin, and you are liable for any shortfall. Diversification and the ability to take long or short positions do not ensure a profit or protect against loss.

Across the cycle

Different environments reward different exposures

The goal is not to find one strategy that wins in every environment — there is not one. It is to combine return sources so the whole portfolio is not making the same bet at the same time.

Growth-led markets

Economic growth is strong, confidence is rising, and stocks do the heavy lifting. A managed futures program may participate in the established trends.

It may also simply lag a straightforward stock allocation, and a client who allocated at the top of an equity run is the most likely to be disappointed early.

Inflationary markets

Inflation can pressure stocks and bonds at the same time while producing large moves in commodities, currencies and interest rates — markets a diversified program already trades.

Opportunity is not the same as profit. Results still depend on how the program is positioned and on whether those price moves persist long enough to be captured.

Recessions and risk-off periods

Falling equity markets, shifting rate expectations and currency moves can create opportunities for a strategy able to take short positions as well as long ones.

Managed futures are not assured to profit in a recession or a crisis. Sharp, fast declines can be the hardest conditions of all for a program that needs a move to persist.

Directionless or reversing markets

Prices change direction repeatedly without going anywhere. This is the environment most likely to hurt a managed futures allocation, and it can last a long time.

Trend-following programs in particular can take a string of small losses while waiting for a stronger move to develop. Expect to sit through this at some point.

The part nobody puts in a brochure

Portfolio design gets discussed in mathematical terms, but people experience risk emotionally. A portfolio can be correct on paper and still fail, because its declines cause the person holding it to abandon it. Selling after a sharp fall turns a temporary loss into a permanent one, and moving to cash creates a second hard decision: when to go back in.

Adding managed futures will not remove uncomfortable periods. The strategy will have its own losses, and there will be times when every part of the portfolio is negative at once. What a complementary allocation may do is reduce how much the whole plan depends on one source of performance — and for some investors, a portfolio whose risks are understood is one they are more able to keep.

Start with the portfolio you already have

Most people do not need another disconnected investment. They need each holding to serve a clear purpose. A traditional portfolio may already provide participation in long-term growth, dividend and interest income, exposure to domestic and international markets, and a level of stability suited to the investor.

The question is not whether to throw that out. It is whether the whole portfolio leans on the same few return drivers — and if it does, whether an allocation with a different process belongs beside it.

How it is structured

Your account, your name, your authority to revoke

BTR works through separately managed accounts rather than pooled funds. That distinction is most of the answer to “where is my money and who can touch it.”

  • The account is opened in your name at a futures commission merchant.
  • The trading advisor receives limited authority to direct trading, and nothing more.
  • The advisor generally cannot withdraw your funds.
  • You can review balances, positions and transactions whenever you want.
  • You receive the results of your own account, not a share of somebody else’s.
  1. Read the disclosure document

    Every registered advisor has to give you one before you can fund an account. It sets out the program, the fees, the principals, the past performance and the risks in a format the NFA prescribes. It is not marketing, and it is the single most useful thing you will read.

  2. Open and fund the account

    The account is opened in your name at the clearing FCM. Your money goes into segregated customer funds at that firm, not to the advisor and not to us. You sign a limited trading authorization giving the advisor permission to trade it, and nothing beyond that.

  3. The advisor trades the program

    They place orders according to the program you were shown. Positions are marked to market every day, so gains and losses settle daily rather than accruing quietly until you sell.

  4. You watch it, and you can stop it

    Daily statements from the FCM, plus consolidated reporting from us if the account runs alongside others. If you want out, you revoke the authorization and the positions get closed. There is no redemption window to wait for.

Customer funds used for exchange-traded futures are required to be held separately from the clearing firm’s own money, though segregation does not remove every custodial or insolvency risk. The CFTC sets out those requirements for futures commission merchants (opens in a new tab), and its Futures Market Basics (opens in a new tab) pages advise prospective customers to weigh their objectives and resources and read the required risk disclosures before trading. A separately managed account is not automatically right for everyone: minimums, liquidity terms, trading approach, leverage, fees, tax treatment and drawdown risk all have to be weighed. Closing an account does not undo losses already realized, and positions are closed at prevailing market prices, which may be worse than the prices at which they were opened.

What it costs

Four charges, all of them disclosed in advance

Fees vary by advisor and by program, so the numbers belong in their disclosure document and in your account paperwork rather than on a web page. What does not vary is the list of things you can be charged for.

Management fee

Charged by the trading advisor as a percentage of the assets in the program, whether it makes money or not. The rate is stated in their disclosure document.

Incentive fee

A share of new trading profits, typically subject to a high-water mark, meaning the advisor has to recover a previous loss before earning it again. Also stated in the disclosure document. Ask how it is calculated and over what period — the mechanics vary more than the headline rate does.

Commissions and exchange fees

Charged per contract traded, covering execution, clearing and the exchange and regulatory fees that come with it. A program that trades often costs more to run than one that does not, and that difference is real money rather than a rounding error.

Platform and data, where applicable

A managed account rarely needs a front end, since you are not placing the trades. Where a program requires specific market data or hosting, that gets set out before you start rather than appearing on a statement.

Fees and trading costs reduce returns, and an account can pay management fees and commissions in a period in which it loses money. Specific fees applicable to any program are set out in the trading advisor’s disclosure document and in your account agreements. Read both before funding.

The part most pages skip

What can go wrong

Anyone can list the reasons to allocate. These are the reasons not to, and you should be satisfied with your answer to each before you fund anything.

  1. You can lose money, including more than you deposit

    Leverage means losses are calculated on the full contract value rather than on the margin posted. A move against the position can exceed the cash in the account, and you are liable for the shortfall.

  2. Drawdowns are normal, and they are long

    Every disclosure document has a worst peak-to-valley drawdown figure. Read it and assume you will experience one. The common failure is not the drawdown itself but closing the account at the bottom of it, which turns a paper loss into a permanent one.

  3. Past performance tells you less than it appears to

    A track record describes conditions that have already happened. Programs that did well in one regime have gone on to do badly in the next, and there is no reliable way to tell in advance which is which.

  4. Correlation is not a constant

    The argument for the category rests on it behaving differently from stocks and bonds. That relationship is measured over history, it drifts, and it can converge exactly when you were relying on it not to.

  5. Markets can move when you cannot

    Limit moves, gaps between sessions and periods of thin liquidity all mean a position may not be exitable at the price you last saw. Stop orders do not guarantee an execution price.

  6. You pay in the losing years too

    Management fees and commissions are charged on activity and assets, not on results. An account can finish a year down and still have paid to get there. Incentive fees are usually the only charge tied to profits, and a high-water mark only limits paying twice for the same recovery.

  7. The size of the allocation decides whether any of this matters

    Too small and it cannot change how the portfolio behaves, so you carry the complexity and the paperwork for an effect you will not notice. Too large and you have swapped one concentrated bet for another. Both mistakes are common, and the second one is the expensive one.

  8. The advisor is a person, and people change

    Style drift, key-personnel departures, growth past a program’s capacity and outright operational failure are all real. This is why programs get monitored after the allocation rather than only before it.

Futures trading is complex and carries the risk of substantial losses. It is not suitable for all investors and you should not rely on any of the information herein as a substitute for the exercise of your own skill and judgment in making a decision on the appropriateness of such investments. Diversification does not assure a profit or protect against loss in declining markets. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.

Questions

Thirty questions people ask before they allocate

Grouped, because most people arrive with one group at a time. Nothing here is advice about your situation — it is what we would tell anyone who asked.

The basics

What the thing is, before anything about whether it suits you.

What exactly are managed futures?

An investment program in which a professional trading advisor directs positions in futures contracts, and where permitted related instruments, in an account opened in your name. The term covers a wide range of approaches rather than one strategy: some are rules-based and run by computer models, others rely on the judgment of the people running them, and holding periods range from months to minutes.

Is this the same as a hedge fund?

No. In a hedge fund you buy an interest in a pooled vehicle and own a share of somebody else’s book, on their subscription and redemption terms. In a separately managed account the positions are held in your own name, you see them daily, and the trading authorization is yours to revoke.

How is it different from a managed futures mutual fund or ETF?

Those are pooled products: you buy shares, the manager runs one book for everyone, and you get the fund’s result rather than your own account’s. A separately managed account gives you your own positions, your own statements and the ability to stop the trading authority directly. The structures also differ on fees, minimums, tax treatment and liquidity, and one is not automatically better than the other.

What markets can a program actually trade?

Depending on the program: stock index futures, government bond and short-term interest-rate futures, currency futures, crude oil, natural gas and refined products, gold, silver and industrial metals, and agricultural markets such as corn, wheat and soybeans. A long market list does not by itself mean every market is actively traded or that risk is spread evenly across them — managers can still build concentrated exposures.

What does it mean that a program can go short?

A short position is designed to gain when a market falls, and a futures contract can be sold before it is owned as easily as it can be bought. That gives the manager the ability to look for opportunity in either direction. It does not make the position safe: shorts lose money when markets rise, and a sudden reversal can hurt long and short positions at once.

Systematic or discretionary — does it matter?

It matters for understanding what you own, not for ranking one above the other. A systematic manager follows model-generated rules; a discretionary manager relies more on professional judgment. Neither approach is inherently superior, and both can be wrong for long stretches.

Do I need to know anything about futures to do this?

You do not place the trades, so you do not need to know how to work a platform. You do need to understand the structure, the leverage and the size of loss the program has historically produced — because you are the one deciding whether to fund it and whether to stay through a drawdown. If a program cannot be explained to you in language you follow, that is information about the program.

Who actually makes the trading decisions?

The trading advisor, under the limited authority you grant in writing. BTR is an Introducing Broker: we introduce and service the account and handle execution and reporting around it. We do not direct the program’s trading.

Your account and your money

Where the money sits, who can reach it, and how you get it back.

Whose name is the account in?

Yours. It is opened at a futures commission merchant — the clearing firm — in your name, and the positions in it are yours rather than a share of a pool.

Does the trading advisor ever hold my money?

No. Funds sit in segregated customer accounts at the clearing FCM. The trading authorization lets the advisor place orders; it does not let them move money out. BTR does not accept or hold customer funds either.

What does “segregated funds” mean, and what does it not protect against?

Customer money for exchange-traded futures has to be kept apart from the clearing firm’s own money, held in accounts titled for customers’ benefit, and it receives priority treatment in a bankruptcy. What segregation does not do is remove every custodial or insolvency risk, and it does not protect you from trading losses at all. The CFTC sets out the requirements on its own site.

How much do I need to start?

The minimum is set by each trading advisor rather than by BTR, and it varies with the markets a program trades and the size of the positions it takes. We can work with allocations to managed futures starting around $10,000, though the practical range for most programs is higher.

How liquid is it? Can I get my money out?

Futures markets are often liquid, but liquidity varies by contract and by conditions, and open positions have to be closed before cash is free. There is no redemption window in the way a fund has one, and there may still be withdrawal procedures and contractual notice requirements that delay immediate access. Ask about both before funding.

Can I stop the advisor trading?

Yes. You revoke the limited trading authorization and the positions get closed. Bear in mind that closing does not undo losses already realized, and positions close at prevailing market prices, which may be worse than the prices at which they were opened.

Can I hold this in an IRA or another retirement account?

Some retirement structures permit it, subject to the custodian accepting the account type and the advisor accepting that structure. Whether it is permitted and whether it is appropriate for your retirement savings are two separate questions, and the second one is for you and your own advisor.

What statements and reporting do I get?

Daily statements from the clearing FCM covering balances, positions and transactions, which are the official record. Where an account runs alongside others, BTR can provide consolidated reporting on top of that.

Risk, leverage and drawdowns

The questions worth being uncomfortable about before you fund anything.

Can I lose more than I deposit?

Yes. Losses are calculated on the full contract value rather than on the margin posted, so a move against the position can exceed the cash in the account, and you are liable for the shortfall. This is the single most important difference between futures and buying a stock.

What is a drawdown, and how big should I expect one to be?

A drawdown is the fall from a previous account high to a subsequent low. Every disclosure document states the program’s worst historical peak-to-valley drawdown and how long recovery took. Read those two numbers, assume you will experience something like them, and decide in advance whether you would hold through it — because the common failure is not the drawdown, it is closing the account at the bottom of one.

Will managed futures protect my portfolio in a crash?

No, and any presentation implying otherwise should be treated with suspicion. A strategy able to take short positions may find opportunity in a falling market, but managed futures are not assured to profit in a recession or a crisis, and sharp fast declines can be among the hardest conditions for a program that needs a price move to persist. They are a potential diversifier, not insurance.

What is notional funding, and should I use it?

It means funding an account below its nominal trading level — $250,000 of trading level on $100,000 of cash, say — while the program trades as though the full amount were there. Percentage gains and losses are both magnified against the cash actually deposited and margin calls arrive sooner. It is a legitimate structure some investors use deliberately, it is not a discount, and it is not a good default for a first allocation.

What happens if I get a margin call?

The clearing firm requires additional funds to support the positions, generally quickly. If the call is not met, positions can be liquidated without further discussion, at whatever prices are available, and any resulting shortfall remains your obligation.

How volatile is this compared with stocks?

It depends entirely on the program and on how much leverage it runs, and it is not safe to assume it sits anywhere in particular relative to an equity allocation. Look at the program’s own monthly return dispersion and its worst drawdown rather than at the category, and remember that leverage can be adjusted, so historical volatility may not describe how the program is run today.

What conditions tend to hurt these strategies?

Markets that change direction repeatedly without going anywhere. Trend-following programs in particular can take a long string of small losses while waiting for a stronger move to develop, and that environment can last considerably longer than most people expect when they allocate.

What if the advisor changes their approach or stops trading?

Style drift, key people leaving, a program growing past the capacity of its strategy and outright operational failure are all real possibilities. This is why a program gets monitored after the allocation rather than only before it, and why the authority to revoke matters. Tell us if something in a program’s behavior stops matching what you were shown.

Costs, allocation and choosing a program

How to compare two programs, and how much of the portfolio the answer should touch.

What am I charged?

A management fee on assets, an incentive fee on new trading profits usually subject to a high-water mark, and commissions and exchange fees per contract traded. Where a program needs specific market data or hosting, that is set out before you start. All of it is disclosed in advance, and an account can pay fees in a year in which it loses money.

How is BTR paid, and does that affect what I am shown?

BTR is compensated through commissions on the trades placed in your account, and arrangements with trading advisors are documented and disclosed as required. The full detail appears in your account paperwork before you sign it. If a program is not a fit for what you are trying to do, we would rather say so.

How large an allocation makes sense?

That depends on your objectives, resources, liquidity needs, time horizon and tolerance for loss, so there is no general answer and anyone offering one does not know enough about you. What is worth knowing is the shape of the tradeoff: a small allocation may have too little influence on the total portfolio to be worth the complexity, while a large one introduces more strategy-specific risk than many investors will sit through.

How do I read a track record?

Read the disclosure document rather than a summary of it. Look at the worst peak-to-valley drawdown and how long recovery took, how many months are in the record, whether assets under management grew faster than the strategy’s likely capacity, and whether the recent period looks like the earlier one. Rate of return is the least informative number on the page.

Are the performance figures I am shown actual or hypothetical?

Always establish which, because it changes what the numbers mean. Hypothetical, pro forma and backtested illustrations have inherent limitations: they are prepared with the benefit of hindsight and rely on assumptions that cannot necessarily be reproduced in live trading. Actual accounts can also differ from a composite because of account size, cash flows, execution timing, fees and trading restrictions. BTR provides approved performance information with the accompanying disclosures so you can evaluate the complete presentation rather than a headline number.

What should I ask about a program’s trading philosophy?

Enough to state in your own words where the returns are supposed to come from, even if the implementation is sophisticated. Then: which markets are eligible, what creates a buy or sell signal, how positions are sized, how much leverage may be used, what conditions are favorable and unfavorable, and what would have to change for the results to look different from the record.

How do I judge whether it fits what I already own?

Look at how the program has behaved relative to your existing holdings rather than at its returns in isolation, and remember that the relationship is measured over history and can converge under stress. Our portfolio case studies are built to make that tradeoff easier to see across a range of market environments.

What are the tax consequences?

Most exchange-traded futures fall under a specific US tax treatment that differs from equities, and gains are generally recognized annually whether or not a position was closed. How that applies to you depends on your circumstances and your entity, so it is a question for your tax advisor. We are not one.

Is managed futures suitable for me?

We cannot answer that from a web page, and neither can anybody else who has not looked at your finances. Futures trading is not suitable for all investors. Before opening an account you should review all disclosure documents and consider your financial experience, objectives, resources and willingness to accept a substantial loss — which is the same thing the CFTC advises prospective futures customers to do.

What is the next step if I want to look properly?

Ask us for the approved program materials, which include performance and the disclosures that go with it, and read the case studies to see how an allocation sits inside a whole portfolio. Then decide. The step after reading is not to assume the strategy belongs in your portfolio — it is to work out whether its role is one you want.

Futures trading is complex and carries the risk of substantial losses. It is not suitable for all investors and you should not rely on any of the information herein as a substitute for the exercise of your own skill and judgment in making a decision on the appropriateness of such investments. Diversification does not assure a profit or protect against loss in declining markets. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results. Managed futures programs may employ significant leverage and an investor could lose more than the amount initially committed to margin. Nothing on this page is a recommendation to trade, an offer of any program or advice about your particular circumstances.

Talk to someone who knows.

A quick phone call will tell you more than an hour on any website. Tell us what you are trying to do and we will tell you whether we are the right fit for it.

800-453-4474 [email protected] 414 Main Street, Second Floor, Franklin, TN